Winning Etsy Shop Ideas in 2019 - Bakery

Posted: Jan 16, 2019 by Steve
We are thoroughly researching to find the newest, most successful Etsy bakery shops so you will have a heads up on what ideas are working. Here we highlight the bakery shop winners of 2018 and 2019, where you will learn what bakery products they are selling, how many products they have sold, and who is operating the new, successful shop.

But first, let's understand why Etsy is the go-to place for so many retail businesses. 1.) Sellers avoid the trouble of having to design and develop an e-commerce website from scatch because Etsy has done most of this work for you. 2.) The Etsy user base continues to grow., a website analytics service, shows that as of early 2019 Etsy was the 44th most popular website in the U.S. and ranks 151 in the entire world. site rank in the U.S. was 44 and 151 in the world in Jan 2019 site rank in the U.S. and world 2019

The bottom line is that Etsy is an elite marketplace where millions of people have turned their ideas into action.

Winning Etsy Bakery Business Shop Ideas

Note: These Etsy shops are listed with the most recent additions posted at the top.
My Grandma Baked A Cookie primarily sells pies and cookies. This Etsy shop was opened in 2018 and as of January 16, 2019 they've sold 98 items. The fresh-baked items are old-fashioned chocolate chip cookies, vanilla cranberry chocolate chip cookies, salted caramel peanut butter chocolate pie, caramel apple pie, pecan pie, chocolate bourbon pecan pie, cookie of the month club, maple blueberry pie, orange chia pecan [no artificial sugar], old-fashioned dark chocolate chip cookies, compost bin cookies (by the dozen) and spiced ginger molasses cookies. The company is based in Pocono Lake, Pennsylvania.

Emilys Kitchen Bakes based in Abergavenny, United Kingdom sells brownies. This Etsy shop was opened in 2018 and as of January 16, 2019 they have sold 215 items. The current product list includes trays containing many brownies for each tray. They have chocolate brownie trays, Valentine's treat box, small tray blondies/white chocolate brownies and large brownie trays, and 8 blondies - white chocolate brownies.

New York state-based shop Michelle's Breads specializes in making different types of breads but they also make cookies and vegetable pasta. Since opening for business in late September of 2018 they have made 51 sales from the new shop. The bread products they offer are braided challah bread, white bread, buttered soft pretzels, pretzel rolls, dinner rolls, garlic and herb breadsticks, sweet molasses brown bread, and cinnamon raisin swirl bread. The shop owner is Michelle Peason of Albany, New York.

As of January 16, 2019, Dip It Desserts has sold 330 of their gift package gourmet desserts, since opening for business in April 2018. These product ideas are typically gifts containing: chocolates and cookies, for holidays and special occasions. This company is based in Glenolden, Pennsylvania.

Emilys Kitchen Bakes based in Abergavenny, United Kingdom sells brownies. This Etsy shop was opened in 2018 and as of January 16, 2019 they have sold 215 items. The current product list includes trays containing a number of brownies for each tray. They have chocolate brownie trays, a Valentine's treat box, small tray blondies/white chocolate brownies, and large brownie trays.

Signature Food and Gift based in New Jersey sells pastry liners, cups, bags, and molds. This shop was opened in January 2018 and one year later they have sold 113 items. The shop owner is Richard from Moorestown-Lenola, New Jersey.

The Bakery Company based in New Jersey, in business since 1976, has opened a shop on Etsy. The Bakery Company has only been using Etsy since December 30 2018 but less than three weeks later they have sold 383 pies from their new shop. The types of pie they specialize in are pumkin, butternut, carrot apple crumb, sweet potato, and they also make carrot cake.

As of January 16, 2019, Cookie Cravings Co has sold 45 of their special occasion and holiday-themed cookie items, since opening for business in June 2018. For Valentine's Day they are selling the followng cookies: You are loved Valentines royal icing cookie, Lets avocuddle Valentine's royal icing cookie, Love you a waffle lot Valentine's day royal icing, and the Bee Mine Valentine's royal icing sugar cookie set.

Kookie Krums is a boutique bakery located at 513 Main Street in Dunedin, Florida that has sold 44 products from their new Etsy shop. They offer a large collection cookies, and cookie & cake pop arrangements that resemble a bouquet of flowers. The business is owned by Dunedin, Florida resident Janet Rinaldi.

Glyka Sweets, a family-owned bakery in San Rafael, California, sells handmade traditional Greek baked goods from their new online shop and at 1201 Andersen Dr Suite I in San Rafael. As of as of January 16, 2019 they have sold 76 of their Greek cookie, bread and pastry products.

Kelly Powell of Austin, TX is the owner of the new Sweet Tooth Tools shop that sells jeweled cookie scribe tools/cake testers. This shop has only been in business since December 2018 but has already sold 52 of these unique product ideas that are available in many different styles and colors.

Diva Delicatesse also known as Keto Bakery Delicatesse is owned by Jessica of Edgerton, Wisconsin. This shop has been in business since October 2018, and as of January 16, 2019 it has sold 65 products. Diva Delicatesse products are: diva Pound cake loaf, diva coconut divines, diva candied pecans, gummy yummies, MCT gummy yummies, and diva sweet & spicy candied pecans.

Rachel of Manassas, Virginia is the owner of Sweet Rose Catering. As of January 16, 2019 this cookie baking and dog treat making company has made 87 sales, since joining Etsy in May 2018. Some of the product ideas are adult-themed but the following is a brief list of the more family-friendly products: Valentine's Day heart sugar cookies, baby shower announcement sugar cookies, bachelorette party sugar cookies, snowflake sparkle winter silver blue sugar cookies, bride groom wedding/bridal shower silhouette sugar cookies, star shaped, heart-shaped & circle peanut butter dog treats, and bone-shaped peanut butter dog treats.

The Keto Bakery Shop based owned by Carolin is based in the United Kingdom. As of January 16, 2019 Keto Bakery Shop has tallied up 42 product sales since opening for business in November 2018. A few of the many product ideas that are selling include half loaf sourdough bread, snickerdoodle cookies, pumpkin spice keto donut limited edition, keto meat pies, sweet milky french bread loaf, wild berry yogurt & white chocolate sugar free pralines, keto low carb protein seeded bread rolls, low carb cinnamon rolls, plain keto bread UK sandwich style, pizza swirls with cheese, tomato and herbs and keto burger buns.

Belia's Bakery is owned by Belia Turley of Honolulu, Hawaii. This online shop has sold 75 coconut macaroon products in just a few months of operation. A macaroon is a small cookie made from ground almonds, coconuts or other types of nuts.

This new Etsy shop, The Ugly Bakery, owned by Lake Worth, Florida resident Yesenia Collura has sold 120 products as of January 2019. Some of these successful handmade baked product ideas are keto/low carb Monkeyy Cookie bars, keto/lowcarb vanilla bean scones, keto/low carb jumbo banana nut muffins, keto/low carb blueberry scones, keto/low carb snickerdoodle cookies, keto bundt cakes, keto/low carb peanut butter cookies, mini Kentucky butter bundt cakes, New York style super crumb cakes & muffins, snickerdoodle cookie bars, chocolate chip oreo surprise, and peanut butter & jelly cupcake jars.

Victory Rolls Bakery based in Beech Grove, Indiana has made 603 sales through the new Etsy shop as of January 2019. Victory Rolls Bakery is owned by Amy Norcross whose product ideas include keto-based pastries such as her keto pistachio shortbread, keto cinnamon sugar donuts, keto red velvet bars, keto lemon shortbread, keto dark chocolate, keto sweet tart sugar cookie bars, and keto double chocolate chip cookies, Some of her traditional pastires are sugar cookie bars, maple pecan braids,chocolate crinkles, raspberry jam bars, and brown sugar cinnamon pop tarts.

Countryside Bakery Co based in Cato, New York offers old fashioned pies And pastries, with 91 sales since July 2018. The shop is owned by Ruth from Cato, New York. Some of the handmade baked goods available are chocolate whoopie pies, chocolate valentines cookies, pumpkin chocolate chip whoopie pies, double crust cherry rhubarb pie, chocolate chip oatmeal cookies, peanut butter round-up cookies, rhubarb pie, pear mincemeat pie, rhubarb blueberry pie, molasses cookies, and peanut butter blossom cookies.

CakeD By Niqua based in Laurel, Maryland has made 70 sales since 2018. This shop is owned by Niqua Wheatley. She makes custom cookies, cakes, tarts and rolls from scratch. Some of her winning items are butter spritz cookies, mini cinnamon swirl pound cake loaves, jumbo caramel pecan cinnamon rolls, jumbo cinnamon rolls with cream cheese icing, iced oatmeal cookies, Nutella stuffed chocolate chip cookies, Oreo stuffed chocolate chip cookies & brownies, double chocolate peppermint cookies, dulce de leche walnut brownies, white chocolate macadamia nut cookie brownies, salted caramel chocolate chip pecan cookies, Virgin Islands guava tarts & cup tarts, mini chocolate chip banana bread loaves and white chocolate macadamia nut cookies.

Small Frys Catering is a new Etsy business started in 2019 with five product sales as of January 15, 2019. They offer vegan chocolate chip cookies.


We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.
Home | Unclaimed Money | Home-based | Successful People | Privacy Policy | Amazon Affiliate Disclosure |

Top of page